Posted on November 18, 2026
Surgery always carries some risk, and not every disappointing outcome means something went wrong on the surgical team’s part. But when a mistake happens that an average surgeon within the same specialty would not have made, the consequences can be serious and lasting. Understanding what counts as a surgical error, how these mistakes happen, and what your options are can help you make sense of what you’re going through.
Before any procedure, your surgeon should walk you through the risks involved, including possible complications like infection, bleeding, or an adverse reaction to anesthesia. These are considered known risks: outcomes that can happen even when a surgeon does everything right. This type of pre-procedure discussion with your doctor is known as informed consent.
A surgical error is different. It’s a preventable mistake that falls below the accepted standard of care, something an average surgeon in the same situation would not have done. The distinction matters because harmful outcomes as a result of known risks that may occur without negligence generally aren’t grounds for a malpractice claim, while surgical errors may be.
Surgical errors can happen at any stage of a procedure, from pre-operative planning through recovery. Some of the most well-known case types include:
These mistakes can lead to additional surgeries, infections, permanent injury, or in the most serious cases, death.
Surgical errors are rarely the result of one isolated decision. They may stem from breakdowns in communication or process, including but not necessarily limited to:
Because these breakdowns often involve more than one person, responsibility for a surgical error isn’t always limited to the surgeon. Nurses, anesthesiologists, and the hospital itself can also share liability depending on what went wrong and why.
If you believe something went wrong during your or a loved one’s surgery, a few general broad steps may help protect both your or your loved one’s health and options:
Not every surgical error rises to the level of medical malpractice, and not every bad outcome is the result of an error at all. To file and maintain a valid medical malpractice claim in New Jersey or Pennsylvania, typically (with a few discrete exceptions), expert support from a healthcare provider or providers in the same specialty as the provider(s) you believe were negligent must be formally secured. Additionally, your lawyer must be able to prove the following:
Because these cases require reviewing medical records and consulting with independent medical experts, the only way to know for certain whether you have an actionable claim is to have your case evaluated in detail.
There’s no set value for a surgical error case and generally speaking, every medical malpractice case is different and has its own unique valuation. The law allows compensation for various types of damages, both economic and non-economic in nature, which may include some or all of the following:
You can see examples of past results on our recent verdicts and settlements page.
If your surgery didn’t turn out as expected and you believe a mistake was made, you are not alone in your quest to figure out whether you have an actionable case. An attorney experienced in medical malpractice can review your medical records, consult with independent medical experts to secure the support necessary to file a claim on your behalf, and help you understand what happened and what options you may personally have.
Contact Weiss & Paarz today to arrange a free consultation.
Known risks are complications that can occur even when a surgeon meets the accepted standard of care, such as infection or an adverse reaction to anesthesia, and patients are informed of these possibilities before the procedure. A surgical error, by contrast, is a preventable mistake that falls below the standard of care, such as operating on the wrong site or leaving an instrument inside the body. The distinction matters because only errors that fall below the standard of care may give rise to a malpractice claim.
Common surgical errors include wrong-site or wrong-patient surgery, retained surgical instruments or sponges, anesthesia errors, nerve or organ damage, and inadequate post-operative monitoring. Each of these can happen at different stages of the surgical process, from pre-operative planning through recovery.
Start by seeking any medical care you need to address the immediate issue. From there, request copies of your medical records, document your symptoms and any conversations with your care team, and consider having an attorney and independent medical expert review your case to determine whether the standard of care was met.
Not necessarily. A disappointing or unexpected outcome alone doesn’t establish malpractice, especially for elective or cosmetic procedures where results can vary. A potential case depends on whether a healthcare provider failed to meet the accepted standard of care and whether that failure caused your injury.
No. Surgery carries inherent risks even when performed correctly, and some complications are unavoidable. Malpractice requires showing that a healthcare provider’s care fell below what a reasonably competent surgeon would have provided under similar circumstances, and that this failure caused real harm.
Compensation in a surgical error case may include medical expenses, costs of additional treatment or surgery, lost wages, and pain and suffering. The value of a claim depends on the severity of the injury and its long-term impact, and is best assessed through a case evaluation with an attorney.
How Much Does a Doctor Visit Cost? In the U.S., a primary care visit without insurance typically costs $40 to $300, with an average... Read more
In-hospital mortality rates are often used as a measure of a hospital’s safety based on past patient outcomes. However, these rates can change over... Read more
Every year, hundreds of thousands of people suffer strokes, making stroke one of the leading causes of death and long-term disability in the United... Read more
Answers may only be a phone call away. Call 1-800-952-8444 or fill out our web submission form and our team will contact you to evaluate whether we can help with your potential claim on your behalf.
Two Bala Plaza, Suite 300 Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004
923 Haddonfield Road, Suite 300 Cherry Hill, NJ 08002
40 Bey Lea Rd, Building C, Floor 2 Toms River, NJ 08753